topics
tools
Expatica countries
editor's choice

Crime and the legal system in the UK

Tips for understanding the Brits

Banking in the UK

Culture and social etiquette in United Kingdom

Museums in London

Index Last Var.(%)
BEL 20 2304.58 1.43
DAX 6766.67 1.67
IBEX 30 8861.2 1.01
CAC 40 3427.92 1.52
FTSE 100 5901.07 1.81
AEX 326.33 1.01
DJIA 12862.23 1.23
Nasdaq 2905.66 1.61
FTSE MIB 16439.62 1.00
TSX Composite 12577.28 0.19
ASX 4320.1 -0.30
Hang seng 20756.98 0.08
Straits Times 2917.95 0.58
ISEQ 20 506.95 2.24
You are here: Home Employment Employment Information EU Blue Card: competing with the US Green Card?
Enlarge font Decrease font Text size


22/09/2009EU Blue Card: competing with the US Green Card?

EU Blue Card: competing with the US Green Card? The EU must compete with the likes of the US to attract and retain highly qualified third-country workers. So how does the new EU Blue Card compare with the US Green Card?

Related Articles

On 25 May, the Council of the European Union adopted the Blue Card Directive, aimed at establishing more attractive conditions for third-country workers to take up highly qualified employment in the EU, by creating a fast-track procedure for issuing a special residence and work permit: the ‘EU Blue Card’.

The Blue Card—similar to the Green Card of the Unied States—is intended to facilitate the holder’s access to the EU labour market and entitle them to a series of socio-economic rights and favourable conditions for family reunification and movement across the EU. The ultimate goal is to attract and retain highly qualified third-country workers, for whom the EU must compete with the likes of Australia, Canada and the US, which alone attracts roughly twice as many skilled workers, according to AFP.

 


EU Blue card compared to US Green card

 

Permanent residency: Blue Card does not give permanent residency; Green Card gives holder permanent residency.
Validity: Blue Card valid up to four years, renewable; Green Card valid for 10 years, renewable.
Permissions: Blue Card allows holders and families to live, work and travel in participating EU states; Green Card allows holder to live, work and travel in the US.
Application criteria: Blue Card applicant must have one-year EU work contract with salary of three times minimum wage; Green Card applicants apply via several channels, including employment, family links, investment. and a lottery.

While the EU Blue Card does not give permanent residency, holders are intended to enjoy equal treatment with nationals of the member state issuing the Blue Card, as regards:

  • working conditions, including pay and dismissal;
  • freedom of association;
  • education, training and recognition of qualifications;
  • a number of provisions in national law regarding social security and pensions;
  • access to goods and services, including procedures for obtaining housing, information and counselling services and
  • free access to the entire territory of the member state concerned within the limits provided for by national law.

Moreover, while the Blue Card directive defines common criteria for the member states which have signed up for the scheme to set for Blue Card applicants, these criteria are not intended to overrule any exisitng national legislation concerning the admittance of migrant workers, which may be more attractive than those set down in the Blue Card directive. For instance, each member will retain its autonomy to maintain and introduce new national residence permits for any purpose of employment, and its autonomy to determine how many third-country workers are admitted.

The 24 member states who have signed up for the Blue Card Directive have two years—till 19 June 2011—to transpose the directive into national law. Only time will tell whether the Blue Card will be successful in drawing highly skilled workers to Europe, over traditionally more popular destinations like the US.

 

For further information, please contact Edith de Bourgraaf or Anne Kwint of Ernst & Young:

Edith de Bourgraaf: +31 10 406 85 42, edith.de.bourgraaf@nl.ey.com
Anne Kwint: + 31 88 407 12 54, anne.bijleveld@nl.ey.com



4 reactions to this article

GreenCardApplicant posted: 2009-09-23 01:44:08

Not a chance the best people will move to the EU. Blue Card compares with the H1B program from the US and not the Green Card at all. The Green Card's permanent residency feature is the reason why people from India and China move to the US. Eventually one can apply for American citizenship in 5 years time.

Take Canada's green card program. Permanent residency right from the start. You can apply for citizenship in 3 years time.

boodine posted: 2009-09-23 12:11:38

one big difference will be if you can actually get a Blue Card. US Immigration is a joke, they make you jump through so many hoops, and then they still drag stuff out forever.

eurocks posted: 2009-10-01 11:17:03

Let alone that Europe is way more fun, diverse and interesting to work than US. ;-)

Luke posted: 2011-01-15 09:00:01

If I moved to the USA to New York and wanted to move to Los Angeles, there would be no permits required. Additionally, only one language substantially simplifies the process. I thought about Europe, until I learned about the taxes!

Europeans are bothered that you are in their country. You always considered a foreigner even maybe you live 10 years!

4 reactions to this article

GreenCardApplicant posted: 2009-09-23 01:44:08

Not a chance the best people will move to the EU. Blue Card compares with the H1B program from the US and not the Green Card at all. The Green Card's permanent residency feature is the reason why people from India and China move to the US. Eventually one can apply for American citizenship in 5 years time.

Take Canada's green card program. Permanent residency right from the start. You can apply for citizenship in 3 years time.

boodine posted: 2009-09-23 12:11:38

one big difference will be if you can actually get a Blue Card. US Immigration is a joke, they make you jump through so many hoops, and then they still drag stuff out forever.

eurocks posted: 2009-10-01 11:17:03

Let alone that Europe is way more fun, diverse and interesting to work than US. ;-)

Luke posted: 2011-01-15 09:00:01

If I moved to the USA to New York and wanted to move to Los Angeles, there would be no permits required. Additionally, only one language substantially simplifies the process. I thought about Europe, until I learned about the taxes!

Europeans are bothered that you are in their country. You always considered a foreigner even maybe you live 10 years!

Looking for a job?

Browse all jobs
ask your question
Discussion Forums

Community Noticeboard United Kingdom

Republicans Abroad Europe

Discuss UK Culture

Financial planning for US citizen resident in UK

Discuss UK Culture

Win prizes by filling out Expatica Survey 2011!

Community Noticeboard United Kingdom

Win prizes by filling out Expatica Survey 2011!

Discuss UK Culture

Movie theaters in London for foreign films?

participate in the forums

Inside Expatica
Visas for coming to the UK

Visas for coming to the UK

Visa paperwork Whether you're relocating to the UK or just visiting, it's important that you find out in advance whether you need a visa.

An online guide for expats finding & purchasing a UK Property

An online guide for expats finding & purchasing a UK Property

Expat mortgages and everything to do with buying a UK property might sound complicated, but there’s plenty of help out there for you.

UK healthcare: Finding the right NHS service

UK healthcare: Finding the right NHS service

You can access the UK's National Health Service (NHS) in a range of ways. Here is an overview of the main services available to help you get the treatment you need.

Banking in the UK

Banking in the UK

Just moved to the UK? You'll need a bank account to effectively manage your money while you're here. Cliff Govender explains the UK banking system, including facilities that may come in handy down the line.